Serhiy Hirik. Jewish National Communist Parties and the Comintern: A Non-Mutual Association

Jewish National Communist Parties and the Comintern: A Non-Mutual Association

By Serhiy Hirik

(The M. S. Hrushevsky Institute of Ukrainian Archeography and Source Studies of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine)

Source: Judaica Ukrainica 2 (2013): 113–125

Publication date: December 1, 2013

Publication type: article

Language: English

Full text: 

 

Abstract

In this paper, the author has attempted to trace the evolution of the politics of the Jewish national communist parties (the left wing of Bund / the Communist Bund, the Jewish Social-Democratic Workers Party (Poale Zion) and its successors: The Jewish Communist Party (Poale Zion) and the The Jewish Communist Workers Party (Poale Zion)) toward the Comintern. At the same time the author presents an analysis of changes in the politics of the Third International toward these parties. The dependence of the ultimate fate of all of these parties on their allegiance to their original program objectives is demonstrated. The author shows that the readiness of the organization to reject features of its ideology helped it to be absorbed by the ruling party of Bolsheviks. In contrast, the strict position on the base postulates provided to the entire isolation after which the enforced liquidation of such political organization was only a matter of time.

 

References

“[Rezoliutsiia] Ob otnoshenii k melkoburzhuaznym partiiam.” In Tretii zizd Komunistychnoi partii (bil’shovykiv) Ukrainy, 1–6 bereznia 1919 roku, edited by Stanislav Hurenko et al., 201–202. Kyiv: Parlaments’ke vydavnytstvo, 2002.

“Extracts from an ECCI Statement on the Decision of the Poale Zion not to Affiliate to the Third International.” In The Communist International, 1919–1943: Documents, edited by Jane Degras, 365–366. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1956.

“Tsirkuliar No 1 Ukr. Tsentr. PB EKP (Poalei-Tsion) ko vsem partiinym organizatsiiam.” Kommunisticheskoie slovo: Biulleten’ Ukrainskogo tsentral’nogo partiinogo biuro Evr. Kom. Partii (Poalei-Tsion) 2 (1919): n.p.

Barngol’ts, M., and Gerr, M. “Rezoliutsiia o politicheskom momente (t.t. M. Barngol’tsa i M. Gerra).” Nakanune: Organ tsentr. komiteta EKP (Poalei-Tsion) 1 (1919): 10.

Beinin, Joel. “The Palestine Communist Party 1919–1948.” MERIP Reports 55 (1977): 3–17.

Gerr, M. “Rezoliutsiia o nashei palestinskoi deiiatel’nosti (t. M. Gerra).” Nakanune: Organ tsentr. komiteta EKP (Poalei-Tsion) 1 (1919): 11–12.

Gerr, M., and Khashin, A. “Nash palestinizm (rezoliutsiia t.t. Khashina i Gerra).” In Ievreiskaia kommunisticheskaia partiia. Rezoliutsii i postanovleniia, priniatyie na Vtoroi vsepartiinoi konferentsii, sostoiavsheisia v gor. Khar’kove 16–23 iiunia 1920 goda, 18. Kharkov: n.p., 1920.

Gurevitz, Baruch. “The Liquidation of the Last Independent Party in the Soviet Union.” Canadian Slavonic Papers / Revue Canadienne des Slavistes 18, no. 2 (1976): 178–186.

---. National Communism in the Soviet Union, 1918–1928. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press, 1980.

Kuras, Ivan. Torzhestvo proletarskogo internatsionalizma i krakh melkoburzhuaznykh partii na Ukraine. Kyiv: Naukova dumka, 1978.

Mints, Isaak, ed. Neproletarskiie partii Rossii: Urok istorii. Moscow: Mysl’, 1984.

Naiman, Oleksandr. Ievreis’ki partii ta obiednannia Ukrainy (1917–1925). Kyiv: Instytut politychnykh i ethnonatsional’nykh doslidzhen’ NAN Ukrainy, 1998.

Piatnitskii, O., Manuils’kii, D., Knorin, V., Kun, B., and Zorkii, M., eds. Vtoroi Kongress Kominterna, iiul’–avgust 1920 g.: Protokoly. Moscow: Partiinoe izdatel’stvo, 1934.

Rafes, Moisei. “Ievreiskoie kommunisticheskoie dvizheniie.” Kommunisticheskii Internatsional 9 (1920): 1299–1308.

---. Dva goda revoliutsii na Ukraine (Evoliutsiia i raskol Bunda). Moscow: Gosudarstvennoie isdatel’stvo, 1920.